Butterflies as Pests?

Yesterday this innocent-looking white butterfly landed on a coworker’s hard hat and I made her stand still so I could take a photo before it flew away.

010 (1024x767)

This is a male Pine ButterflyNeophasia menapia. I first became aware of their existence shortly after moving here, when I noticed a brochure tacked up on the wall at my office – an update from the previous year on a Pine Butterfly outbreak in the local national forests. Like many butterflies, these are tied to a specific plant to complete their life cycle – in this case, their caterpillars feed on the needles of Ponderosa Pines and Douglas-firs. Unlike many butterflies, they occasionally have large outbreaks that can damage forests, which happened here last year. (Incidentally, the Forest Service brochure reassured anyone reading it that despite the damage “…they are not ‘eating all the trees,'” and I felt like those quotation marks conveyed a lot of frustration and weariness on the part of the Forest Service staffer tasked with educating the public on this issue. Doubtless he/she had fielded a lot of phone calls from people demanding that the agency do something about those butterflies eating all the trees.)

Anyway, I’m not used to thinking of butterflies as pests, but people around here who know almost nothing else about butterflies seem to know that white butterflies eat pine trees. (I’ve already found myself explaining at least once that no really, there are a lot of different kinds of white butterflies and only one actually eats pine trees, so please, please don’t just smoosh any white butterfly you see). The outbreak has died down somewhat since last year, and today was the first time I’d actually spotted any of the butterflies in question. It got a fair amount of media coverage at its height, though, including this great NPR piece complete with video of the butterfly “snowstorm.”

I looked briefly for any signs of eggs or caterpillars on the needles of the trees around us, but without time for a more thorough search I wasn’t able to find any. In any case, like so many things in nature, these insects are a little more complicated than we might like them to be. Butterflies are nice, pests are bad – which one is this?

3 replies on “Butterflies as Pests?”

And then you grow a garden, and realize that every tomato hornworm and caterpillar you smash would otherwise grow into a gorgeous Sphinx moth or some other pretty, colorful, winged thing. I’m always fascinated by how nature as it really is tends to turn our cultured expectations on their heads!

We have just recently had Giant Swallowtails expand into eastern Ontario. This is a southern species that was normally restricted to Point Pelee/Windsor. However, climate change seems to be making it easier for it to extend its range further north and east over the past three years. I was surprised, then, to discover that its caterpillars are considered pests because they feed on citrus trees! We don’t have any orange trees here, but we do have Prickly Ash – another favoured foodplant – and the caterpillars are welcome to it! (By the way, this is the first new butterfly species that has moved into the Ottawa area since I started butterflying about 7 years ago, so it’s exciting for me. We also have two new dragonfly species, both within the last 3 years as well!)

I can’t see them as pests. If common milkweed was considered valuable, Monarchs would be considered pests. It’s all about perspective and what we humans consider to be economically valuable. For the butterflies, it’s about survival.

Leave a Reply to Erin Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s